In one of wrong or misunderstood cases in recent history, Albuquerque, New Mexico jury of 79 year-old Stella Liebeck $ 2,900,000 for severe burns suffered after he poured a cup of coffee, McDonald's knee, which had placed between them.
The jury award was $ 200,000 in damages and $ 2,700,000 for punitive damages (because of the McDonald's insensitive behavior). The jury also found Mrs. Liebeck 20% negligent,Minimize the damage at $ 160,000. The judge also reduced the punitive damages to $ 480,000.
Mrs. Liebeck did not receive $ 2,900,000, or $ 2,860,000, or $ 740,000. The parties had a post-sentence for an undisclosed amount.
(The Member States have different legal standards of negligence. New Mexico used a comparative negligence rule, we assign the debt and therefore proportional judgments. Other states like North Carolina with a non-contributoryNegligence standard, which prevents a plaintiff from recovery if their actions have contributed to 1% for the incident!)
THE FACTS OF THE CASE
Mrs. Liebeck, while a passenger in his nephew bought the car with a cup of coffee at the drive-thru window at McDonalds. As the car was stopped, they found the cup between her knees and tried to remove the cover. The inverted cup and poured the scalding (180-190 ¡F) hot water on his knees.
Yousuffered third degree burns on 16 percent of his body. During his eight day hospital stay she underwent skin grafts and treatment for painful whirlpool debridement (removal of damaged tissue), their wounds. He has large scars and has been locked for over two years.
Despite this very painful and debilitating injuries and their costly medical treatment, Ms. Liebeck offered to settle with McDonald's for $ 20,000.
McDonald's refused to settle and the case went toStudio.
FACTS ON FIRST STREET
The jury heard testimony from the following:
McDonald's coffee sales or $ 1,300,000 per day.
or the specific company, sold McDonald's caused their coffee at 180 to 190 degrees Fahrenheit, the coffee at that temperature, if spilled, third-degree burns (the skin is gone and burned to the muscle / layer of adipose tissue) in 2 -7 seconds and third-degree burns do not heal without skin grafting, debridement and whirlpoolTreatments that cost tens of thousands of dollars and lead to permanent disfigurement, extreme pain and disability of the victim for many months and sometimes years;
o The Director of the Department of Mechanical Engineering and Bio-engineering at the University of Texas testified that the risk of damage is not acceptable, Widely recognized as an expert on burns, the director of the main scientific journal in the field of specialty chemicals , Journal of Burn Care andRehabilitation;
Or McDonald's has admitted that she is known about the risk of serious burns from hot coffee warm for more than 10 years – the danger was brought to its attention through numerous other claims and suits, to no avail;
o From 1982 to 1992, the McDonald's coffee burned more than 700 people, many receiving severe burns in the genital area, perineum, thighs and buttocks;
or Not only men and women but also children and children are burned by McDonald'shot coffee, in some cases by accidental spillage of McDonald's employees;
Or at least one woman had dropped the coffee in her lap through the service window, causing third degree burns to her inner thighs and other sensitive areas, which resulted in disability policy for years;
Witnesses or for McDonald's admitted in court that the consumer, the magnitude of the risk of serious burns from spilled coffee to McDonald's serving temperature;
Or McDonald'sadmitted that they did not warn customers about the nature and extent of this risk and could not explain why they do not provide;
Or McDonald's witnesses testified that it will not turn down the heat – As one witness wrote: "No, there is no current plan, the process we are now using change in that direction;
Or McDonald's has admitted that its coffee is not fit for human consumption "when sold because it can cause burns if spilled or drunk;
O Liebeck'sdoctor testified that her injury burns burns one of the worst he had ever seen.
o The Shriner Burn Institute in Cincinnati had published warnings to the franchise food industry that its members would serve to unnecessarily severe burns scalding beverages to 130 degrees Fahrenheit.
By refusing to grant a new trial on the case, Judge Robert Scott called McDonald's behavior "callous." Moreover, "the day after the verdict that documents the mediathat coffee from McDonald's in Albuquerque [where Liebeck was burned] is now sold to 158 degrees. This will cause third-degree burns in about 60 seconds, instead you have 58 seconds [so] the margin of safety was raised as a direct consequence of this ruling. "
Wayne C Walker, President of Capital Transaction Group Inc. a leading provider of financial services disputes – captran.com.
This information is opinion and not legal advice.Readers should not act upon this information without seeking the advice of a competent attorney.
© 2003 CapTran
credit : interactiveshaq.com